Caffrey is originally from Chuluota, Fla. and played for Winter Springs

Following a prestigious high school and club career Caffrey went on to play at West Virginia and then Florida State University. Caffrey competed in both indoor and outdoor volleyball and graduated in 2020. 

Here indoor accolades include: 

AVCA East All-Region Team (2019)
All-ACC First Team (2019)
Preseason All-ACC Team (2019)
AVCA All-American Honorable Mention (2018)
AVCA All-East Region Player of the Year (2018)
AVCA All-East Region Team (2018)
ACC Player of the Year (2018)
All-ACC First Team (2018)
VolleyballMag.com Power 5 Player of the Week (11/8)
ACC Player of the Week (11/5)
ACC Player of the Week (10/16)
ACC Player of the Week (9/24)
Home2 Suites Tallahassee Seminole Invitational All-Tournament Team (2018)
All-Tournament Team, Colorado State Tournament (2018)
Preseason All-ACC (2018)
AVCA All-Midwest Regional Honorable Mention (2017)
All-Big 12 First Team (2017)
Big 12 Co-Offensive Player of the Week Nov. 27 (2017)
Diet Coke Classic All-Tournament Team (2017)
WVU Invitational All-Tournament Team (2017)
Preseason All-Big 12 (2017)
AVCA Midwest Region Freshman of the Year (2016)
WVU Athletics Rookie of the Year (2016)
WVU Volleyball Offensive MVP (Team Award, 2016)
AVCA All-Midwest Region Team (2016)
Big 12 All-Conference First Team (2016)
Big 12 All-Freshman Team (2016)
Five-time Big 12 Freshman of the Week (2016)
WVU Invitational MVP (2016)
Named to Penn State Classic All-Tournament Team (2016)
Named to Cal Classic All-Tournament Team (2016)
Two-time WVU Student-Athlete of the Week (2016)

​

During the 2020 Beach season Caffrey Finished the season with a perfect 13-0 record and as one of six individuals that finished the season undefeated with more than 10 matches played…played all 13 matches with freshman Liz Waters-Leiga…the pair went 12-0 on court four and 1-0 on court three…earned seven ranked wins, including wins over No. 9 Stetson, No. 7 Cal Poly, No. 10 Grand Canyon and No. 4 USC…held her opponent to 10 or fewer points in a set six times…along with Waters-Leiga she outscored her opponent by an average of 7.6 points per set win on her way to dominating all 13 matches she played